← All articles

Refinance vs. Cash-Out Refinance: How to Choose

· By the HomePilot team · Reviewed by a licensed loan officer · Company NMLS #2752340

Refinance vs. Cash-Out Refinance: How to Choose

A standard refinance (also called rate-and-term) replaces your mortgage with a new one for roughly what you still owe, to change your rate, your term or your loan type. A cash-out refinance replaces it with a larger loan and hands you the difference in cash. The first is about improving the loan you have. The second is about turning equity into money. The right choice depends on what you need the new loan to do.

HomePilot Mortgage
Compare Your Refinance Options
HomePilot Mortgage compares your refinance options across 40+ wholesale lenders, with quotes available in minutes and no hard credit pull to start.
Compare refinance options

TL;DR

  • A rate-and-term refinance keeps your balance about the same and changes the rate, term or product. A cash-out refinance raises your balance and pays you the extra at closing.
  • Cash-out loans generally carry a slightly higher rate because the lender takes on more risk, and they allow a lower maximum loan-to-value ratio.
  • Both replace your whole mortgage and come with closing costs, so run a break-even number before you commit.
  • If you only need cash and your current rate is good, compare a HELOC or home equity option before you replace the first mortgage.

Table of Contents

What each refinance actually does

Both products pay off your current mortgage with a brand-new one. The new loan has its own rate, its own term and its own closing costs. The difference is the size of the new loan.

Rate-and-term refinance. You are primarily refinancing the remaining unpaid balance. Typical goals: lower the rate, switch from an adjustable to a fixed rate, shorten the term, or drop to a longer term for a smaller payment. No cash comes back to you, apart from small amounts that rules allow in some cases.

Cash-out refinance. Freddie Mac describes it as refinancing for more than you owe, returning a portion of your equity in cash. Fannie Mae’s selling guide says an eligible cash-out transaction gets a new first mortgage on the same property to pay off the existing mortgage debt, and the borrower may take equity out for any purpose. Fannie Mae also attaches eligibility rules, such as seasoning requirements on the existing first mortgage.

What each refinance actually does, overview diagram

In plain terms: if you owe $250,000 and the new loan is $250,000 (plus financed costs, if any), that is a rate-and-term refinance. If the new loan is $350,000 and you receive roughly $100,000 after payoff and costs, that is a cash-out refinance.

Side-by-side comparison

Rate-and-term refinance Cash-out refinance
New loan size About what you owe now More than you owe
Cash at closing None (or minimal) Yes, the extra amount
Main purpose Better rate, shorter or longer term, safer loan type Renovations, debt payoff, big expenses, investing
Pricing Usually the lower rate of the two Generally slightly higher
Maximum loan-to-value Higher Lower than other refinance types
Effect on equity Builds equity faster if the term shortens Lowers your equity on day one
Closing costs Yes Yes, often priced with more risk adjustments

A third pricing point is worth knowing. Because the lender carries more risk on a cash-out loan, the added cost can show up as a higher rate, as points paid at closing, or as a mix of both. Ask for both versions of the quote so you can see the real trade.

How rate, balance and payment change

Rate

Expect the cash-out version of the same loan to price a bit higher. Freddie Mac says this is because you are borrowing more money, which adds risk for the lender. We do not print rates in articles because they change daily. You can see our live numbers beside the national average on our rates page, and you can price your own file on the cash-out refinance and refinance pages.

Balance and term

A rate-and-term refinance can leave your balance flat or lower it. A cash-out refinance raises it. The CFPB points out that a new loan can extend the time it takes to pay off your mortgage: payments may be smaller on a 30-year term than on a 15-year term, but the balance goes down more slowly.

That last point catches people out. If you are 7 years into a 30-year loan and refinance into a new 30-year loan, you have restarted the clock. A lower payment can feel like savings while the total interest you pay over the life of the loan goes up. If the goal is a lower payment, ask for the quote on a term that matches your remaining years too, so you can compare honestly.

Payment

A bigger balance at a higher rate means a larger payment for the same term. Whether it is affordable is a budget question, and it should be answered before you sign, not after. The CFPB warns that converting equity to cash creates debt that must be repaid, and that borrowing more than you need increases total interest and fees.

How much equity can you take out?

This is where the two products part ways most clearly. Lenders and the agencies that buy loans limit how much of your home’s value the new loan can cover. Fannie Mae notes that cash-out refinances have lower maximum loan-to-value ratios than other refinance types. Freddie Mac’s ACE+ appraisal waiver rules, for example, limit cash-out LTV to 70% on primary residences. The cap you actually face depends on the program, the occupancy (primary home, second home or investment property), the number of units and your credit profile.

The math is simple. Take your home’s value, multiply by the cap, then subtract what you owe and your costs.

Example (illustrative only): a home worth $500,000 with a $250,000 balance. If the program cap were 80% of value, the maximum new loan would be $400,000. Subtract the $250,000 payoff and, say, $8,000 in closing costs, and you would have about $142,000 in cash. At a 70% cap, the maximum loan would be $350,000 and the cash would be about $92,000.

Three things set your number:

  1. Appraised value. The appraisal, not an online estimate, drives the math.
  2. Loan program. Conventional, FHA and VA each have their own cash-out rules. Jumbo loans follow lender-specific limits, so check them on our jumbo page.
  3. Credit and occupancy. A primary residence usually allows more than a second home or rental.

Remember that your payoff includes everything you owe on the first mortgage, and any second liens often have to be dealt with at the same time.

What closing costs and break-even look like

Both refinances carry real costs. The Federal Reserve says refinancing costs are usually 3% to 6% of the outstanding principal, and that the costs and procedures are similar to those of the original mortgage, which is why shopping around matters. On a $300,000 balance, that range is $9,000 to $18,000.

The Fed’s break-even method is straightforward: divide your total fees and closing costs by your monthly after-tax savings. The answer is the number of months until the refinance pays for itself.

Example: $6,000 in costs and $200 a month saved gives 30 months. If you plan to sell or refinance again before month 30, the refinance loses money.

Refinance costs divided by savings equals break-even months

This works cleanly for a rate-and-term refinance, where the saving is the whole point. For a cash-out refinance, a monthly saving may not exist at all, since you are borrowing more. The test is different: what is the cost of the cash, and does the use of that cash earn or save more than the cost? Paying off a high-rate credit card may clearly win. Funding a vacation does not.

You can run the numbers yourself with our refinance break-even calculator, and read how a no closing cost refinance trades upfront fees for a higher rate.

When a rate-and-term refinance fits

Freddie Mac says a no cash-out refinance may make sense to lower your rate, switch mortgage products or build equity faster. Typical situations:

  • Your credit has improved or market rates are lower than your current rate.
  • You have an adjustable-rate loan and want a fixed payment.
  • You can afford a higher payment and want to move from a 30-year to a 15-year term.
  • You want to remove or restructure mortgage insurance, where the loan type allows it.

Veterans have a special tool here. A VA cash-out refinance can refinance an existing VA or non-VA loan into a VA-guaranteed loan, while an IRRRL can only refinance a VA loan into another VA loan. If you hold a VA loan and just want a lower rate, read our guide on the VA streamline break-even first.

When a cash-out refinance fits

Cash-out works best when three things line up: you have meaningful equity, your current mortgage rate is not much better than today’s, and the cash has a clear job. Freddie Mac lists home improvements or improving your financial situation as common reasons. In practice we see:

  • Renovations that add value or fix a major system.
  • Consolidating higher-interest debt into one mortgage payment.
  • Buying out a co-owner after a divorce or inheritance.
  • Self-employed owners who need working capital and prefer one fixed payment.
  • Investors pulling equity to fund another purchase.

Be careful with the debt-consolidation case. Moving unsecured debt into your mortgage lowers the rate, but it also puts the debt against your home and stretches it over decades. If the same spending habits return, you could end up with the mortgage and new card balances. Also consider how a larger balance affects your family’s protection if something happens to you; it is worth looking at mortgage life insurance options alongside the new payment.

There is also a credit angle. Any new loan involves a credit inquiry and a new account, and cash-out refinancing can affect your FICO score in the short run. Plan it before a major purchase, not during one.

Cash-out refinance or HELOC?

If your existing first mortgage has a rate you would hate to lose, replacing it just to get cash can be the wrong move. A HELOC adds a second, separate line on top of the first mortgage and leaves the first loan alone. A cash-out refinance replaces everything with one loan. Which wins depends on your current rate, how much you need and whether you want a fixed payment. We walk through the decision in HELOC vs. cash-out refinance, and you can see how our digital HELOC works if you only need a line of credit.

A decision checklist

  1. Name the goal. Lower payment, lower total interest, shorter term, or cash. Pick one main goal.
  2. Write down your current rate, balance and remaining years. These are the numbers every offer is measured against.
  3. Ask for both quotes. Get a rate-and-term quote and a cash-out quote on the same day so you see the price of the extra cash.
  4. Check the cap. Confirm the maximum loan-to-value for your property type and use.
  5. Compare closing costs line by line. Our free Loan Estimate review shows how an estimate you already hold compares with wholesale pricing.
  6. Run the break-even. If you will not keep the loan past that point, do not refinance.
  7. Stress-test the new payment. Make sure it fits your budget with room to spare.

Our perspective

Most people we talk to have already decided which product they want before they have seen both prices. We think that is backwards. A cash-out refinance and a rate-and-term refinance are two quotes for the same house, and the gap between them tells you what the cash costs.

We are a family-owned wholesale mortgage broker. Instead of one bank’s rate sheet, we price every file across 40+ wholesale lenders, keep a thin margin on the winning price and charge $0 in lender fees, with no origination, processing or underwriting charge. That structure matters more on a cash-out loan, where the pricing adjustments are bigger and a small difference in rate is spread over a larger balance. We explain how brokers and banks differ on our blog.

Our view on cash-out is simple: use it for something that pays you back, such as a renovation, high-rate debt or a business need with a clear plan. If you only want a lower rate, do the rate-and-term refinance and keep the debt where it is. We publish live rates beside the national average every business day on our rates page so you can check us.

The HomePilot Team

Get both quotes from us

We lend in Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida and Texas. You can get a quote in minutes, and starting does not require a hard credit pull. Purchases average about 20 days from accepted offer to closing, with a standard commitment of 30 days or less. For eligible fixed-rate conventional, FHA and VA offers, our $500 Best Price Guarantee applies (terms apply). Start on our cash-out refinance page or our refinance page, or run the numbers first in our mortgage calculators. HomePilot Mortgage, NMLS #2752340.

FAQ

Is a cash-out refinance worse than a regular refinance?

Not worse, just built for a different job. It usually carries a slightly higher rate and a bigger balance, so it costs more over time. It makes sense when the cash has a clear, valuable use.

Can I lower my rate and take cash out in the same loan?

Yes, if your current rate is higher than today’s pricing, the new loan can have a lower rate even with a larger balance. Your payment may still go up because the balance is bigger. Compare the full cost and the break-even before deciding.

How much does a refinance cost?

The Federal Reserve says costs are usually 3% to 6% of the outstanding principal. Our lender fees are $0, but third-party costs such as appraisal, title and prepaid items still apply, so compare the full Loan Estimate.

How long should I plan to stay in the home?

Longer than your break-even period. Divide total closing costs by monthly savings to get that number in months. If you expect to move or refinance again sooner, the refinance probably will not pay off.

What is the difference between rate-and-term and cash-out in one sentence?

Rate-and-term changes the terms of the debt you already have, while cash-out increases the debt and pays you the difference.

Sources

HomePilot Mortgage, NMLS #2752340, is a licensed mortgage broker in Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, and Texas. Equal Housing Lender. This article is general information, not a loan offer or a commitment to lend. Rates and program terms change daily and depend on credit, loan amount, and county. HomePilot Mortgage is a private company, not affiliated with or endorsed by the Department of Veterans Affairs, HUD, or any government agency.