← All articles

Remove PMI by Refinancing: When It Pays and When It Doesn't

· By the HomePilot team · Reviewed by a licensed loan officer · Company NMLS #2752340

Remove PMI by Refinancing: When It Pays and When It Doesn't

Refinancing removes PMI when the new loan is a conventional mortgage with a balance at or below 80% of your home’s current value. It is not the only way out, and often not the cheapest. If your balance is near 80% of the original value, asking your servicer to cancel costs far less than a new loan. If your home has gained value, or you are paying FHA mortgage insurance, a refinance may be the right tool. Below is how to tell which situation you are in.

HomePilot Mortgage
homepilotmortgage.com
See If Refinancing Can Remove PMI
Compare your refinance numbers across 40+ wholesale lenders, with $0 lender fees, before deciding whether the savings outweigh closing costs.
Compare refinance options

TL;DR

  • Federal law lets you ask to cancel conventional PMI at 80% of the original value, and requires automatic termination at 78%, if your payments are current.
  • If your balance is above those marks but your home has appreciated, you can ask for cancellation based on current value, or refinance into a loan with no PMI.
  • FHA mortgage insurance follows different rules. For many FHA borrowers, a conventional refinance is the main way to end it early.
  • A refinance has closing costs. Divide them by your monthly savings to find your break-even before you commit.
  • We price every file across 40+ wholesale lenders with $0 lender fees, so you can see the numbers before deciding.

Table of Contents

First, check whether you even need to refinance

Private mortgage insurance is usually required on a conventional loan when the down payment is under 20%, according to Fannie Mae. It protects the company holding the loan, not you. The good news is that it is built to end.

For conventional mortgages closed on or after July 29, 1999, the Homeowners Protection Act gives you two protections, as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains:

  1. Request cancellation at 80%. You can ask in writing once your balance is scheduled to reach 80% of the home’s original value.
  2. Automatic termination at 78%. Your servicer must end PMI when the balance is scheduled to reach 78% of the original value, as long as you are current.

“Original value” is generally the lower of the purchase price or the appraised value at closing. If you refinanced before, it is the appraised value at that time.

That means a refinance is only worth considering when one of these is true:

  • You are years away from 78% on the original schedule, but your home is worth much more than when you bought it.
  • You have an FHA loan, where the cancellation rules above do not apply.
  • You were going to refinance anyway, for a shorter term, a lower payment, or to pull out equity, and PMI removal is a bonus.

If none of those fits, call your servicer first.

What the servicer will check before cancelling

Cancelling at your request is not automatic. The CFPB’s guidance and its Homeowners Protection Act examination handbook point to a few tests. Servicers generally look for:

  • A current loan, with no payment 30 or more days late in the last 12 months
  • No payment 60 or more days late in the last 24 months
  • A single-family principal residence (second homes and investment properties often face tougher equity requirements)
  • Proof that the property has not lost value and has no other liens, such as a second mortgage, that sit ahead of the equity

A servicer may order its own valuation at your expense to confirm eligibility. Policies vary on the paperwork, so ask for the written steps before you pay for anything.

If you miss any of these tests, the servicer does not have to grant your request, whatever your equity looks like. A clean payment record is also what a new lender will want to see, so a failed cancellation request is worth understanding before you apply for a refinance.

Removing PMI based on today’s home value

Removing PMI based on today's home value, overview diagram

Your home may be worth more than it was at purchase. Many owners in Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida and Texas have seen values move since they bought. If so, you may not need to wait for the original amortization schedule.

For loans owned by Fannie Mae, the servicing rules in Lender Letter LL-2018-03 allow borrower-initiated termination based on current value, with these limits:

Loan age (seasoning) Maximum LTV on current value
Under 2 years Generally not eligible on current value
2 to 5 years 75% or less
More than 5 years 80% or less
Investment property or 2 to 4 unit primary residence 70% or less, regardless of seasoning

The valuation is not free. Expect to cover it yourself: roughly $190 for a broker price opinion, or $450 to $750 for an appraisal depending on property type, based on the Fannie Mae servicing guide figures. That guide also says improvements must be substantial to justify a higher value, such as a kitchen renovation or added square footage, and not routine maintenance.

Online estimates will not satisfy a servicer. If you want to understand why, this breakdown of Zestimate versus appraisal value shows how the two numbers differ and which one carries weight when equity is on the line.

Two checks before you order a valuation

  • Ask the servicer whether your loan is owned by Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac or another investor. The seasoning and LTV limits depend on it.
  • Ask what the servicer will accept: a broker price opinion, a full appraisal, or both. Paying for the wrong one wastes money.

When refinancing to remove PMI makes sense

A refinance replaces your loan, so PMI goes away only because the new loan starts at a lower loan-to-value. With a new appraisal showing your balance at 80% or less of value, a conventional loan needs no mortgage insurance.

Refinancing tends to be the better path when:

  • Your value has risen sharply and the current-value route is blocked by seasoning (under two years) or by the servicer’s process.
  • You have an FHA loan and want out of mortgage insurance that does not cancel on equity alone.
  • You want a different loan anyway, such as dropping from a 30-year to a 15-year term, or pulling out equity through a cash-out refinance.
  • Your credit has improved since you bought, which can change the price of the new loan. How scores and loan features adjust pricing is covered in our guide to loan level price adjustments.

It tends to be the wrong move when you are within a year or two of automatic termination, when you would trade a low existing rate for a higher one, or when the closing costs eat the savings.

Removing FHA mortgage insurance

FHA mortgage insurance (MIP) is not governed by the same cancellation rules as PMI. Fannie Mae notes that depending on when your loan originated and how much you put down, FHA mortgage insurance may last 11 years or the life of the loan. Paying the balance down to 80% does not end it.

That is why a refinance into a conventional loan is often the only way to drop the premium before its required term ends. The test is the same as above: after the new appraisal, the balance needs to be at or below 80% of value to avoid PMI on the new loan. If you sit between 80% and 97% LTV, the new conventional loan may carry PMI, but PMI on a conventional loan can later be cancelled, which FHA MIP cannot.

We also offer FHA loans if you want to stay in the program, so the comparison can run both ways.

Veterans have a different situation. VA loans have no monthly mortgage insurance, so there is nothing to remove. If you are a veteran with an existing conventional loan that carries PMI, a VA refinance may be worth pricing, provided you have a 10%+ disability rating or other qualifying service. Eligibility rules apply.

Removing FHA mortgage insurance, overview diagram

Run the break-even before you refinance

The CFPB has said that closing costs can be a significant obstacle to refinancing, and that they can total several percentage points of the loan amount. Many borrowers are also surprised that a refinance needs a new title insurance policy.

The CFPB’s home loan toolkit suggests a rule of thumb: refinance only if you recover the costs within roughly two years. The toolkit also tells borrowers to check existing loan documents for a prepayment penalty.

A worked example (hypothetical numbers)

Say your loan balance is $400,000, your PMI is $150 a month, and a refinance would cost $8,000 in closing costs. This is an illustration, not a quote.

  • Monthly saving from dropping PMI: $150
  • Break-even: $8,000 divided by $150, about 53 months, or a little over four years
  • If you also lower your payment by another $100 a month through a better price, you save $250 and break even in 32 months

The first scenario is longer than the two-year rule of thumb, so cancelling through your servicer, or waiting, may serve you better. The second might justify a refinance. Your own figures will differ, and the cost side is where lenders differ most.

Steps to run your numbers:

  1. Get your current PMI or MIP amount from your mortgage statement.
  2. Get a current estimate of your home’s value, then divide your balance by it to find your LTV.
  3. Collect closing costs from a Loan Estimate, line by line.
  4. Divide total costs by your monthly saving.
  5. Compare that to how long you plan to keep the home.

Our refinance break-even calculator does the division for you. If the costs look high, our guide to no closing cost refinances explains how rolling costs into the rate changes the math, and why it does not make them disappear. Most U.S. mortgages carry no prepayment penalty, but checking yours first takes five minutes.

Our perspective: PMI removal is a math problem, not a sales pitch

We are a family-owned wholesale broker, and we earn when a loan closes. So you should know where we stand: if cancelling PMI with your servicer saves you money, that is the better answer, and we would rather you know it now.

Here is how we think about it:

  • Start with the cheapest route. A cancellation request costs a letter and perhaps a valuation fee. A refinance costs thousands. Use the second only when the first is blocked or when the new loan does more for you than remove PMI.
  • Price the new loan fairly. We price every file across 40+ wholesale lenders, keep a thin margin on the winning price, and charge $0 in lender fees. Origination, processing and underwriting all sit at $0 with us. Third-party costs such as the appraisal and title still apply.
  • Show the numbers. We publish live rates beside the national average every business day on our rates page, so you can compare with anything else you are holding.
  • Check any offer, ours or not. Send us a Loan Estimate and our free Loan Estimate review compares it to wholesale pricing.
  • Know what a guarantee covers. For eligible fixed-rate conventional, FHA and VA offers, our $500 Best Price Guarantee applies: if we cannot beat an eligible competing offer, we pay $500 (terms apply).

A PMI removal refinance usually works best for borrowers who have both built equity and want a better loan structure. When it is only about the PMI line on the statement, we run the break-even with you and say so if it does not pay.

The HomePilot Team

Step by step: how to remove PMI through a refinance

  1. Confirm your loan type. Conventional PMI and FHA MIP lead to different answers.
  2. Estimate your LTV. Divide your balance by a realistic current value. At 80% or below, a conventional refinance carries no PMI.
  3. Pull your payment history. A clean record helps both a cancellation request and a new application.
  4. Get a quote. Compare the new payment to your current payment, including PMI. Make sure you compare like with like, such as the same loan term.
  5. Check the costs. Look at the Loan Estimate and compare closing costs to your monthly saving.
  6. Order the appraisal. The new loan’s value drives whether PMI is needed.
  7. Close and confirm. Check your first statement to verify no mortgage insurance is charged.

On purchases, our loans average about 20 days from accepted offer to closing, with a standard commitment of 30 days or less. Refinance timelines vary with the appraisal and title work, so ask for the schedule when you request your quote.

Start with a quote that does not touch your credit

We can price your refinance, or a conventional or FHA loan, across 40+ wholesale lenders in minutes. A first quote involves no hard credit pull. We are licensed in Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida and Texas (NMLS #2752340). Details on the program are on our refinance page. If you are weighing the loan against pulling cash out, see HELOC versus cash-out refinance.

FAQ

Can you remove PMI if you refinance?

Yes. When the new conventional loan starts at 80% LTV or lower based on a new appraisal, it generally carries no PMI. The saving has to outweigh the closing costs, so run the break-even first.

How do you get PMI removed without refinancing?

Write to your servicer when your balance is scheduled to reach 80% of the original value, or ask for a review based on current value if your loan meets the seasoning and LTV limits. You need a current payment record and may have to pay for a valuation. At 78% of the original value, termination is automatic if you are current.

Do you have to wait 5 years to remove PMI?

Not always. For Fannie Mae loans, current-value cancellation needs at least two years of seasoning, with a 75% LTV limit between two and five years and 80% after five. Cancellation on the original schedule has no five-year wait, but it depends on your loan’s amortization.

Can FHA mortgage insurance be cancelled like PMI?

Not by paying down to 80%. FHA mortgage insurance can last 11 years or the life of the loan, depending on the loan. Refinancing into a conventional loan is often the way to end it early.

Does refinancing reset the PMI clock?

A new loan sets a new original value, based on the new appraisal. If you finish with more than 20% equity there is no PMI to cancel. If you finish with less, the new schedule starts over, so avoid refinancing into a high LTV unless the savings are clear.

Sources

HomePilot Mortgage, NMLS #2752340, is a licensed mortgage broker in Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, and Texas. Equal Housing Lender. This article is general information, not a loan offer or a commitment to lend. Rates and program terms change daily and depend on credit, loan amount, and county. HomePilot Mortgage is a private company, not affiliated with or endorsed by the Department of Veterans Affairs, HUD, or any government agency.